What are index funds?

Index funds are a popular way to invest in the performance of entire markets. They track stock market indices such as the DAX (German stock index) or MSCI (Morgan Stanley Capital International) World, enabling broad risk diversification. But what exactly are index funds, and how do they work? This article provides a straightforward explanation of how index funds are structured, their advantages, and how to invest in them—whether you're a beginner or looking to expand your investment strategy.

• Index funds replicate the performance of a stock market index, such as the DAX or MSCI World, offering a simple, cost-effective, and well-diversified way to invest long term

• ETFs are exchange-traded index funds that are more flexible and often cheaper than traditional index funds

• Historically, broad indices like MSCI World or S&P (Standard & Poor’s) 500 have achieved annual returns of around 6–8%, minus costs

• To start, you'll need a securities account, and you can invest either with a lump sum or regularly through a savings plan

What is an index fund?

An index fund is an investment fund that mirrors the performance of a specific stock market index. A stock market index, such as the DAX or MSCI World, summarises the performance of selected securities, particularly shares, to represent a specific market or sector. For instance, the DAX measures the performance of the 40 largest companies in the German stock market, including Adidas, Allianz, BASF, Bayer, Deutsche Bank, Henkel, RWE, SAP, Volkswagen, and many more (as of December 2024).

What makes index funds unique is their passive nature. They aim to replicate the composition and performance of an index as closely as possible. This distinguishes them from actively managed funds, where fund managers make targeted buy and sell decisions to outperform the market.

Index funds are particularly popular because they offer investors a low-cost and straightforward way to participate in the performance of major markets. They are suitable for both beginners and experienced investors looking to diversify their portfolios without relying on complex strategies.

Index funds vs ETFs: What's the difference?

ETFs (exchange-traded funds) are a type of index fund traded on the stock exchange, making them more flexible and often cheaper than traditional index funds. Although both replicate the performance of a stock market index, they differ in trading accessibility and structure. Another key distinction lies in replication methods: ETFs typically use physical replication by directly purchasing the securities in the index, while index funds may also use synthetic or optimised replication methods.

Key differences between ETFs and index funds:

• Trading: ETFs are traded on the stock exchange and are available flexibly during trading hours, while index funds are settled once daily via the fund company

• Costs: ETFs often have lower ongoing fees, while index funds may include upfront and redemption charges

• Replication methods: ETFs predominantly use physical replication, whereas index funds may use synthetic or optimised methods

• Use case: ETFs are ideal for active investors seeking trading flexibility, while index funds are often used in long-term savings plans

Both offer distinct advantages. ETFs excel in flexibility and lower costs, while index funds are well-suited for long-term, automated investments.

How do index funds work?

Index funds operate on a replication principle: they track the performance of a stock market index like the DAX or MSCI World. Instead of being actively managed, an index fund follows a predetermined structure that automatically adjusts to match the index.

This passive strategy involves replicating an index by holding its securities, such as shares or bonds, in the same weighting. Depending on the method, the fund may directly buy the relevant securities (physical replication) or use financial instruments like derivatives to replicate the index's performance (synthetic replication).

The result is a broad diversification across all the securities in the index, allowing investors to benefit from dividends that contribute to returns. This provides balanced risk distribution and market returns without the additional costs and decisions associated with actively managed funds. The simplicity and efficiency of index funds make them an appealing option for long-term investors.

How to invest in index funds

To invest in index funds, you need a securities account, which you can open with a bank, online broker, or specialised platform. Exchange-traded index funds are purchased directly on the stock exchange via your account, while traditional index funds are available through fund providers, banks, or brokers. Savings plans are particularly convenient for regular investments, allowing you to invest small amounts in index funds automatically.

Steps to invest in index funds:

1. Open a securities account: Choose a bank, online broker, or platform that offers access to index funds

2. Select a fund: Decide which index (e.g., DAX, MSCI World) aligns with your investment goals and select the corresponding fund

3. Choose a purchase method: Decide whether to make a one-off investment or invest regularly through a savings plan

4. Make a purchase: Buy exchange-traded index funds directly on the stock exchange via your account, or purchase traditional index funds through a provider or broker

5. Monitor your portfolio: Keep track of your investment's performance and review regularly to ensure it aligns with your financial goals

With a securities account and the right strategy, you can invest in index funds simply and flexibly. Whether through a one-time purchase or a savings plan, on the stock exchange or directly with a provider, index funds offer versatile options.

Investment strategies for index funds

Before choosing a strategy, consider your financial goals, risk tolerance, and investment horizon:

• Financial goals: Global indices like MSCI World provide diversification, while regional indices like DAX are more focused

• Risk tolerance: Broadly diversified indices reduce risk, while specialised funds offer higher returns but greater volatility

• Investment horizon: Longer periods smooth out market fluctuations, whereas shorter-term investments may require conservative strategies

Two main strategies:

1. Lump-sum investment: Ideal if you have significant starting capital, allowing you to fully benefit from market developments immediately. However, this approach is more exposed to short-term fluctuations.

2. Regular savings plans: Invest smaller amounts regularly, such as monthly, which is especially suitable for long-term wealth building without a large initial sum. This strategy benefits from cost averaging, as consistent payments spread investment over various price levels.

These approaches can also be combined to leverage the advantages of both and tailor investments to your goals.

Costs of index funds

Index funds are known for their low costs, but investors should consider both initial and ongoing fees.

Initial costs:

• Upfront charges: Traditional index funds may include a one-time charge of up to 5% of the investment

• Trading fees: Passive equity index funds incur order fees, usually ranging from 0.1% to 0.3% of the transaction value

• Account fees: Some providers charge for account management, though these fees are often waived by online brokers

Ongoing costs:

• Management fees: The total expense ratio (TER) includes all ongoing costs, typically between 0.1% and 0.5% annually. For example, a TER of 0.3% on €1,000 would amount to €3 per year.

• Tracking difference: Minor deviations between fund performance and index returns due to fees or replication methods

• Rebalancing costs: Expenses incurred when adjusting the fund composition to match the index

This transparent cost structure makes index funds an affordable option for long-term investments.

How much do index funds earn?

Index fund returns directly reflect the performance of the underlying index. Since they aim to replicate the index 1:1, returns usually match average market performance minus costs and plus reinvested dividends. For example, the MSCI World Index has delivered an average annual return of about 9% since its inception in 1975, although results vary depending on market conditions and investment horizons.

Even in the cryptocurrency space, index fund-like solutions, such as crypto indices, enable investors to diversify across multiple cryptocurrencies and benefit from the overall market’s performance, much like traditional index funds.

Conclusion: Overview of the advantages and disadvantages of index funds

Index funds are a simple and cost-effective way to invest in the performance of entire markets. Their passive strategy provides broad diversification and cost savings compared to actively managed funds. However, while they directly mirror market performance, this brings both opportunities and risks. Here's a summary of the main advantages and disadvantages:

Advantages of index funds:

• Cost efficiency: low management fees and no active management costs

• Diversification: broad risk distribution by investing in all components of an index

• Ease of use: no complex investment decisions required

• Market-aligned returns: stable long-term earnings that reflect index performance

Disadvantages of index funds:

• No protection from market downturns: market losses are fully mirrored

• Limited flexibility: fund performance is tied to the index, offering no potential for outperformance

• Tracking differences: minor deviations from the index due to costs or replication methods

Index funds are ideal for investors looking for long-term investments that benefit from market-wide performance and low costs. However, they aren't a guarantee of profit and should align with individual financial goals and risk tolerance.

Further questions about index funds

Here are answers to common questions about index funds in simple terms:

What is an index?

An index is a numerical benchmark representing the performance of a specific market or market segment. Notable examples include the DAX, which covers the 40 largest German companies, and the MSCI World, which represents over 1,500 companies from industrialised nations globally. Indices act as benchmarks for investments like index funds.

Where can you buy index funds?

Traditional index funds are available through fund providers, banks, or brokers. Exchange-traded index funds (ETFs) can be purchased directly on the stock exchange via a securities account, which you can open with a bank or online broker.

What taxes apply to index fund gains?

In Germany, gains from index funds are taxed similarly to other capital income. They are subject to a withholding tax of 25%, plus a solidarity surcharge of 5.5% on that tax amount.

Can you invest in index funds through a savings plan?

Yes, many providers offer savings plans for index funds. ETF savings plans are particularly popular among beginners as they allow you to start with small amounts. Many providers waive purchase fees for savings plans, further reducing costs. By investing small, regular amounts, you can build wealth over time and benefit from cost averaging. ETF savings plans are widely accessible and offer a flexible way to invest without a large initial sum.

Further topics on financial planning

Would you like to learn how to benefit from stock prices and cryptocurrency market movements? The Bitpanda Academy offers a wide range of guides and tutorials, providing deeper insights into blockchain networks, crypto trading, and much more.